People think it’s so impressive to date a doctor or a lawyer. I tend to be unimpressed, and this drives my family nuts.
“Jenny! Why don’t you want to go out with him?! He’s a doctor!”
What? I gotta like the guy because he’s gonna make a lot of money? Do I look like I want a life personal yoga trainers and mani-pedis every week? I think my resistance roots deep into my past when my parents rejected the scruffy ski bums I brought home for dinner. This has created rebellious reaction to elitism: if you don’t like my scruffy ski bums, I won’t like your doctors.
Although I don’t care to date a doctor, a Silicon Valley mogul, or a Harvard graduate, I shouldn’t discriminate against them if they are either. And with what I’m about to share with you now, you’ll see my prejudices against elitism got the best of me when I had a moment of it myself.
For months my parents have wanted me to go out with this doctor my dad’s nurse wanted me to meet. (This was another case of matchmaking based on the mindset that if “he’s Mormon, and she’s Mormon, then they must be a fit!”) I was indifferent to the M.D. subscript to his name, but the fact my family kept pushing “he’s a doctor, Jenny” flipped the rebellion switch in my head and made me want to dig in my heels and cancel the set-up. But, out of courtesy to my dad’s working relationship with his nurse, I agreed to meet him.
Within 5 minutes of giving my number to the nurse to send along to him, I receive a call from the prospect who immediately started quoting from my Facebook page, which he had access to because we were in the same Network (I didn’t know this and immediately changed my privacy settings after the call.) I have to admit I was a little put-off by such a greeting. But I was also hesitated with what he said next.
“Well, let’s do this quick and dirty. Can you meet for breakfast tomorrow at 10 am?”
I agreed before I could let anything else sink in.
As a third year resident, this guy was on a tight schedule. He didn’t have a lot of time free time floating around. I, however, am a horse of a different color. My schedule is almost too flexible, so when things come my way…I pounce on them.
Long story short, I cancelled on this guy 3 times because something always came up—such as having to pick up my sister-in-law and nieces and nephews from Idaho, or jumping into a stranger’s car for a last-minute road trip (blog post for another day).
I really had ever intention to meet him, really, but it just was something, well, that was lower on my To-Do list.
I could sense the frustration in his voice the third time I said, “Well…something came up…I’m going to Montana!” He was candid enough to say, “we don’t have to do this if you don’t want to.”
I assured him I did (and I did), and that I’ll call him when I got home. But by then, any excitement we might have had about meeting each other was nothing but a distant memory, so I decided not to call. That was until my dad called me and asked me not to embarrassed him in front of his nurse. Fine. I’ll call.
I did as soon as I hung up with my father.
“Hello?”
“Hey…it’s Jenny.”
“Oh…hey…”
“I don’t know if you’re still interested…but shall we try this again?”
“Um…Sure.”
“Great. How about tonight? I’m coming down to Salt Lake in a minute.”
“Tonight? Uh…I think tonight will work…”
“Great…and if it’s not a problem, I will have my cousin Ashley with me. We have an Institute class at the U.”
I’m not one for bring a human accessory on a first date, but based our repeated failures to match our schedules, I thought this was our best opportunity.
So…with exactly 54 minutes before we had to race up to the Institute building at the University of Utah campus, we pulled in front of his apartment.
“Okay, Ashley. You have reached a new level as a wingman—a front row seat to a first date.”
When I saw him walk out of his apartment, we had 10 seconds to comment before we it looked weird we weren’t getting out of the car to greet him.
“He has a nice body,” Ashley said. I raised my eyebrows in agreement. Yeah, not bad.
For the next 50 minutes, the three of us chatted over Rubio’s tacos on a beautiful late-summer evening. Our friend had the extra task of repeating every question to me to my cousin, but during this unusual three-way conversation, I found myself kind of liking the guy. It wasn’t so much when I discovered he’s been on the ball his whole life to become a full-fledged doctor by 30, but it was the moment he corrected me when I misquoted a line from Scrubs.
(Sure, it’s unfortunate that his knowledge of a sit-com about doctors is more impressive to me than his knowledge of actually medicine, but it was a slight turn-on.)
But when the conversation turned to school and college (Ashley and I had both gone to BYU, and our friend here attended the U), I said something that was, well, less than impressive to him.
First, a little background: while growing up in Provo, the majority of my high school class went to two schools: BYU or UVSC (the local state school). Generally speaking, BYU was everyone’s first choice, but if you didn’t have the grades for it you went to UVSC. This may or may not have been the case for the entire school, but it was in the circle of Mormon friends I knew.
So when I asked this guy where most of his high school friends (particularly Mormon friends) went to school, I was surprised to hear him say most of them chose the U.
My homogenous, Utah Valley upbringing chimed in before my post-BYU enlightenment had a chance to stop it. “And they choose the U because they couldn’t get into BYU?”
And that killed the jukebox. He lowered his glasses, and by the time I processed what I had just said, I already felt a painful ray of judgment coming from this guy’s furrowed brow.
“Not everyone thinks BYU is the only school in the world.”
I’m sorry, I said, and tried to give him some context. “Where I grew up, people only went to other schools if they didn’t get into BYU. I mean, it is the best academic school in the state. Why choose an inferior school if you could attend superior one?”
He didn’t like that either.
Anyway, Ashley and I soon had to leave to make it to Institute class where I could sit and write notes to Ashley accusing her of being a horrible wingman for not stopping me from talking.
All and all, I see two ironies come from this whole thing. First, I’m really quite indifferent to BYU. I don’t feel very much loyalty to the school, and I probably wouldn’t go there again if I could do it over, so it’s pretty funny that when I finally say something positive about BYU, my comment bites me like this.
And second, here I am pre-judging this guy to be an elitist because he’s a doctor and I come out with swinging with comments implying his alma matter was filled only with students rejected from mine. Ha!
For the record, BYU is a great school, as is the University of Utah, and I really don’t care what kind of school sweatshirt a guy would proudly wear. (Except if it said Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardy. If a guy wore a Harry Potter sweatshirt in front of me, I wouldn’t date him.)
I actually wouldn’t mind going out again and talking more about Scrubs, but I haven’t heard from him since.


